May
Hochul for Congress, Erie County clerk will do a better job with the problems facing America
The Buffalo News
By Editorial Board
May 14, 2011, 10:49 PM
The race to win the congressional seat vacated by former Rep. Chris Lee, R-Clarence, features three main candidates, one of whom — businessman Jack Davis — remains primarily focused on a single issue, free trade. The other two — Erie County Clerk Kathleen Hochul and Assemblywoman Jane Corwin — are each well-suited to the job at hand, but we have a narrow but clear preference for Hochul.
Both women are capable and well informed. Both cite the federal budget deficit as a commanding issue, and both understand the need to fix the financial problems facing Medicare, the health care program for seniors.
But Hochul has a more rounded grasp on the role of government in the 21st century. She understands health care for seniors to be an appropriate federal issue, while Corwin does not. More conservative than even many Republicans in Western New York, Corwin holds a pinched view of Washington’s role in public life, restricting it to issues such as defense, transportation and food safety.
In meeting with The Buffalo News editorial board, she didn’t specifically say that issues such as health, education and the environment were inappropriate for government, but the implication was clear. She supports the Republican proposal for Medicare, which would turn it into a voucher system. To be sure, Medicare needs to be fixed to preserve it for future beneficiaries, but not this way.
Frankly, if the goal were simply to cut the deficit, Corwin, of Clarence, would be the choice. She brings the business person’s approach to government in much the same way as her mentor, Erie County Executive Chris Collins. But that shouldn’t be the only goal.
The aim must be to gain control of the deficit while protecting the environment, ensuring medical care for seniors, setting standards for education and, yes, defending the nation, facilitating transportation and keeping our food supply safe.
That requires political skill and an ability to balance the role of government with the hard facts of arithmetic. Hochul is clearly better suited to that task, and she brings years of experience with her.
As a public servant, Hochul streamlined the county clerk’s office and expanded services. She has made one of the bugaboos of all drivers — dealing with the local DMV — a more satisfying experience by shortening wait times and focusing on customer service. She takes pride in having criticized the plans of fellow Democrats: former Gov. Eliot Spitzer for proposing to give driver’s licenses to illegal immigrants and former Gov. David Paterson for planning to mandate new license plates in the midst of a recession.
Davis is making his fourth run for Congress — previously as a Democrat but this time, after being rebuffed by the Republicans, as an independent Tea Party candidate. He is passionately opposed to free trade, the issue that drove his previous campaigns. We admire his passion but doubt his approach.
His prescription for the deficit is not to cut domestic spending, but to “level the playing field” on trade, thus putting unemployed Americans back to work and creating sufficient tax revenue to refill Washington’s coffers. To help in that quest, he would also eliminate foreign aid to “countries that hate us,” halt military action in Libya and bring troops home from Iraq and Afghanistan.
Some voters are responding to that message — enough that Republicans are worried about Corwin’s prospects — but it’s a tunnel-vision view of the nation’s vexing problems.
In the end, the decision on which candidate to support hinges on which one you think will better represent the interests of Western New Yorkers and the nation.
Both Corwin and Hochul have made an issue of the deficit, but Hochul’s skills and record suggest a deeper understanding of the role of government in modern life. Changes need to be made, and soon. Hochul is the candidate with the best ability to push for those changes while guarding against an assault on the role of government itself.
